Car Surveillance Systems: Your Vehicle is a Tracking Device
🔑 Key Takeaways
- Always-on tracking: Modern cars continuously monitor location, speed, and driving behavior
- Data sharing networks: Automakers sell your data to insurance companies, advertisers, and law enforcement
- Remote access capabilities: Vehicles can be remotely tracked, disabled, or have doors unlocked
- Microphone surveillance: Many cars have always-listening capabilities for voice commands
- Limited privacy controls: Most surveillance features cannot be disabled without affecting core functionality
Your Car is a Computer on Wheels
Modern vehicles contain more computing power than the Apollo spacecraft that went to the moon. The average car today has over 100 sensors, multiple cameras, always-on internet connectivity, and sophisticated data collection systems that would make tech companies jealous.
Every modern vehicle is essentially a surveillance platform that happens to provide transportation. Your car knows where you've been, where you're going, how you drive, who you call, and what you say. This data is collected continuously and shared with a network of corporations and government agencies.
⚠️ The Surveillance Reality
According to Mozilla's Privacy Not Included research, cars are the worst product category for privacy. All major automakers collect and share personal data, often with little transparency or user control.
Data Collection in Modern Vehicles
Location and Movement Tracking
Every connected car is a GPS tracking device that creates a detailed record of your movements:
- Real-time location: Continuous GPS tracking with minute-by-minute positioning
- Route history: Complete logs of all trips, destinations, and stops
- Timing patterns: When you leave for work, return home, and visit locations
- Speed monitoring: Real-time speed tracking and speeding incidents
- Parking locations: Where you park and for how long
- Geographic profiling: Analysis of your movement patterns and lifestyle
Driving Behavior Analysis
Cars monitor every aspect of your driving behavior:
- Acceleration patterns: How aggressively you accelerate and decelerate
- Braking behavior: Hard braking events and emergency stops
- Cornering forces: How you take turns and handle curves
- Lane positioning: How well you stay in your lane
- Following distance: How closely you follow other vehicles
- Distraction indicators: Erratic driving that may indicate phone use
Vehicle System Monitoring
- Engine performance: RPM, fuel consumption, and efficiency metrics
- Maintenance needs: When services are due and what repairs are needed
- System diagnostics: Error codes and component status
- Usage patterns: How often you use different vehicle features
- Environmental conditions: Weather, road conditions, and ambient data
Major Automotive Surveillance Systems
OnStar: GM's Comprehensive Tracking Platform
General Motors' OnStar system is one of the most extensive automotive surveillance platforms:
- Automatic crash response: Monitors for accidents and automatically calls emergency services
- Stolen vehicle assistance: Can remotely locate and disable stolen vehicles
- Remote diagnostics: Monitors vehicle health and sends alerts
- Turn-by-turn navigation: Tracks all navigation requests and destinations
- Hands-free calling: Records call metadata and voice interactions
- WiFi hotspot: Internet connectivity that logs all connected devices
🔧 OnStar Data Collection
OnStar collects and can share:
- Location data: Current and historical location information
- Speed and direction: Real-time driving behavior data
- Vehicle diagnostics: Mechanical and electronic system status
- Usage patterns: How and when you use your vehicle
- Emergency events: Accidents, airbag deployments, and panic button uses
Ford's SYNC and FordPass
Ford's connected car platform collects extensive data through multiple systems:
- FordPass app: Remote start, lock/unlock, and vehicle status monitoring
- SYNC infotainment: Voice commands, phone integration, and usage tracking
- Modem connectivity: Always-on cellular connection for data transmission
- Driver assistance systems: Lane keeping, adaptive cruise control, and parking assist data
Tesla's Comprehensive Surveillance
Tesla vehicles are among the most surveilled cars on the road:
- Multiple cameras: Eight external cameras recording continuously
- Cabin camera: Interior camera monitoring driver behavior
- Autopilot data: Detailed logs of all autonomous driving attempts
- Over-the-air updates: Remote access to vehicle systems and software
- Supercharger network: Tracking of all charging sessions and locations
- Mobile app integration: Complete remote control and monitoring capabilities
SiriusXM and Satellite Radio Tracking
Satellite radio systems provide another layer of vehicle surveillance:
- Signal tracking: Precise location data from satellite signal reception
- Listening habits: What stations and content you prefer
- Travel patterns: Location-based content and advertising targeting
- Account integration: Links to payment methods and personal information
Insurance Company Vehicle Monitoring
Telematics and Usage-Based Insurance
Insurance companies increasingly use vehicle data to adjust premiums and investigate claims:
- Progressive Snapshot: Plug-in device or app monitoring driving behavior
- State Farm Drive Safe & Save: Smartphone app tracking driving patterns
- Allstate Drivewise: Device-based monitoring with discount incentives
- GEICO DriveEasy: App-based monitoring of speed, braking, and phone use
What Insurance Telematics Monitor
- Speed and acceleration: How fast you drive and how aggressively
- Braking patterns: Hard braking events that indicate risky driving
- Time of day: When you drive (late night driving considered riskier)
- Mileage: How much you drive affects risk calculations
- Location data: Where you drive and park
- Phone usage: Whether you use your phone while driving
⚠️ Insurance Surveillance Risks
Data collected for "discounts" can be used against you in claims investigations. Insurance companies can deny claims based on telematics data, even if you weren't at fault in an accident.
Law Enforcement Access to Vehicle Data
Automatic License Plate Readers (ALPRs)
Police departments nationwide use ALPR systems to track vehicle movements:
- Fixed cameras: Stationary ALPR cameras on roads and intersections
- Mobile units: Police cruisers equipped with ALPR technology
- Database storage: License plate sightings stored for months or years
- Real-time alerts: Immediate notifications for vehicles of interest
- Pattern analysis: Tracking routine movements and identifying associates
Manufacturer Cooperation with Law Enforcement
Automakers regularly share vehicle data with law enforcement:
- Subpoena compliance: Providing location and usage data upon request
- Emergency requests: Real-time tracking for active investigations
- Stored data access: Historical movement patterns and behavior analysis
- Remote vehicle control: Disabling vehicles or unlocking doors for police
Event Data Recorders (EDRs)
Most vehicles since 2013 include EDRs that record detailed crash data:
- Pre-crash data: Speed, braking, and steering in seconds before impact
- Crash dynamics: Force, direction, and severity of impact
- Safety system status: Whether seatbelts were worn and airbags deployed
- Legal evidence: EDR data is admissible in court proceedings
Third-Party Data Sharing Networks
Data Broker Integration
Automotive data feeds into the broader surveillance economy:
- LexisNexis Risk Solutions: Combines driving data with credit and background information
- Verisk Analytics: Insurance risk assessment using telematics data
- Acxiom and Experian: Consumer profiling using location and behavior data
- Location analytics companies: Retail and advertising targeting based on travel patterns
Advertising and Marketing Uses
- Location-based advertising: Targeted ads based on places you visit
- Retail analytics: Shopping pattern analysis for marketing purposes
- Demographic profiling: Income and lifestyle inference from vehicle and travel data
- Competitive intelligence: Businesses tracking competitor customer visits
Smart Car Security Vulnerabilities
Remote Hacking and Control
Connected cars are vulnerable to cyber attacks:
- Remote access exploits: Hackers gaining control over vehicle systems
- Key fob attacks: Signal amplification and replay attacks
- Infotainment vulnerabilities: Malware through USB ports and wireless connections
- OTA update hijacking: Intercepting and modifying software updates
- CAN bus attacks: Direct manipulation of vehicle control systems
Notable Vehicle Hacking Incidents
- 2015 Jeep Cherokee hack: Researchers demonstrated remote control over steering and brakes
- Tesla Model S vulnerabilities: Multiple security flaws allowing remote access
- BMW ConnectedDrive flaw: Vulnerability allowing remote door unlocking
- Volkswagen hack: Criminals using key fob signal amplification for theft
Privacy Protection Strategies
Disabling Vehicle Tracking Systems
⚠️ Legal Disclaimer
Disabling vehicle tracking systems may void warranties, affect safety features, and potentially violate terms of service. Some modifications may also affect vehicle operation or safety systems.
OnStar and GM Vehicles
- Cancel OnStar service: Call 1-888-4-ONSTAR to cancel subscription
- Request data deletion: Ask for deletion of historical location data
- Disable cellular modem: Physical disconnection may be possible (affects other features)
- Check privacy settings: Review and opt-out of data sharing in vehicle settings
Ford SYNC and FordPass
- Delete FordPass account: Remove the mobile app and associated data
- Disable modem connectivity: Pull the cellular modem fuse (affects updates and features)
- Factory reset SYNC: Clear all personal data from the infotainment system
- Opt-out of data sharing: Use vehicle privacy settings to limit data collection
Tesla Privacy Settings
- Disable data sharing: Turn off data sharing in vehicle settings
- Sentry Mode considerations: Understand that Sentry Mode records surroundings
- Cabin camera privacy: Cover or disable interior camera if possible
- Mobile app limits: Remove the Tesla app or limit its permissions
Physical Countermeasures
- Faraday pouches for key fobs: Prevent signal amplification attacks
- GPS signal jammers: Block GPS signals (illegal in many jurisdictions)
- Cellular signal blocking: Faraday cage for the vehicle (impractical for daily use)
- Microphone disconnection: Physical disconnection of voice command microphones
- Camera covering: Block interior and exterior cameras where possible
Operational Security for Vehicle Privacy
- Cash purchases: Buy vehicles with cash to limit financial tracking
- Avoid connected features: Choose vehicles with minimal internet connectivity
- Regular data clearing: Periodically clear personal data from vehicle systems
- Separate devices: Don't connect personal phones to vehicle systems
- Alternative transportation: Use public transit, bicycles, or car-sharing for sensitive trips
Insurance and Financial Implications
Telematics Insurance Programs
Understanding the true cost of "discount" insurance programs:
- Rate increases: Poor driving scores can increase premiums
- Claims investigation: Telematics data used to dispute claims
- Policy cancellation: Extreme driving behavior may lead to policy termination
- Data retention: Insurance companies keep data even after program participation ends
Alternatives to Surveillance-Based Insurance
- Traditional insurance: Choose insurers that don't require telematics
- Privacy-focused insurers: Research companies with better privacy policies
- State insurance programs: Some states offer insurance with limited data collection
- Self-insurance: In some jurisdictions, bonding instead of insurance
The Future of Vehicle Surveillance
Emerging Technologies
- 5G connectivity: Faster, more comprehensive data transmission
- Vehicle-to-everything (V2X): Communication with other vehicles and infrastructure
- Advanced driver assistance: More sensors and cameras for autonomous features
- Biometric monitoring: Driver identification and health monitoring
- Predictive analytics: AI-powered behavior prediction and intervention
Regulatory Developments
- European GDPR compliance: Stronger data protection requirements for automakers
- California privacy laws: CCPA and CPRA affecting vehicle data collection
- Federal legislation: Potential nationwide vehicle privacy regulations
- Insurance regulation: State-level rules on telematics and pricing
Choosing Privacy-Friendly Vehicles
Older Vehicle Advantages
- Pre-2013 vehicles: Generally lack comprehensive tracking systems
- Mechanical systems: Fewer electronic components to compromise
- No internet connectivity: Cannot transmit data to manufacturers or third parties
- User-repairable: Easier to modify or disable tracking components
Privacy-Conscious New Vehicle Selection
- Minimal connectivity: Choose models with fewer connected features
- Transparency: Research manufacturers' privacy policies and data practices
- Opt-out capabilities: Select vehicles that allow disabling tracking features
- Independent analysis: Review third-party privacy assessments of vehicle brands
📚 Sources & Further Reading
- Mozilla Foundation. "Privacy Not Included: Cars." https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/privacynotincluded/categories/cars/
- Electronic Frontier Foundation. "What Does Your Car Know About You?" https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2020/03/what-does-your-car-know-about-you
- Federal Trade Commission. "Connected Cars: Trade-off Between Convenience and Privacy." https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/blogs/business-blog/2016/04/connected-cars-trade-between-convenience-privacy
- Senator Ed Markey. "Tracking & Hacking: Security & Privacy Gaps Put American Drivers at Risk." https://www.markey.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/2015-02-06_MarkeyReport-Tracking_Hacking_CarSecurity%202.pdf
- Consumer Reports. "Cars That Keep Your Data Private." https://www.consumerreports.org/car-safety/cars-that-keep-your-data-private/
- Automotive News. "Automakers' Data Collection Under Congressional Scrutiny." https://www.autonews.com/technology/automakers-data-collection-under-congressional-scrutiny
🎯 Take Action
Review your vehicle's privacy settings: Check what data your car collects and opt-out of unnecessary sharing. Consider the privacy implications before enrolling in insurance telematics programs.
Practice digital hygiene: Regularly clear personal data from your vehicle's systems and avoid connecting personal devices to car infotainment systems.